Confronta Counterwallet vs XGo ID Wallet Wallet

Confronta società
As the digital world continues to expand, choosing the right digital wallet becomes increasingly important for the management of our virtual assets. In this article, we will dive into a head to head comparison between two popular wallets - XGo ID Wallet and Counterwallet. This deep comparison will look into their key features, security aspects, ease of use, and more, so you can make an informed decision.
Società
User rating User rating 5 / 5 1 recensione dell'utente User rating 5 / 5 1 recensione dell'utente
Cryptogeek rating Cryptogeek rating 5 / 5 Cryptogeek rating 4.8 / 5
Punteggio di Fiducia Come funziona Punteggio di Fiducia 4.55 / 5 Punteggio di Fiducia 4.13 / 5

About

Counterwallet è un portafoglio web open source anonimo per il protocollo Bitcoin (BTC) e Counterparty (XCP). Counterwallet supporta più lingue. 
XGo ID-Un nome per tutti i tuoi indirizzi Semplifica le tue transazioni crittografiche senza sforzo. Elimina gli indirizzi di portafoglio lunghi e sostituiscili con un singolo nome a tua scelta

Data di lancio

2014 2021

Località:

International International

Lingue

English English, Japanese, Brazilian Portuguese, Portuguese, German, French, Spanish, Italian, Greek, Korean, Russian, Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Simplified Chinese, Dutch, Vietnamese, Portuguese (PT), Turkish, Indonesian, Malay, Filipino, Hindi, Arabic, Thai, Danish, Hungarian, Polish, Czech, Slovene, Slovak, Ukrainian, Estonian, Taiwanese, Romanian, Hebrew, Finnish, Bulgarian, Bengali, Persian, Swedish, Serbian, Icelandic, Urdu, Croatian

Tipo di portafoglio

Software wallet Software wallet

Tipo di storage

Hot wallet Hot wallet

Chiavi private

Disponibile Non disponibile

Monete disponibili

0 359 - Bitcoin (BTC), Basic Attention Token (BAT), IOTA (MIOTA), Tezos (XTZ), Ethereum Classic (ETC), NEO (NEO), VeChain (VET), OmiseGO (OMG), Qtum (QTUM), Verge (XVG), Lisk (LSK), ICON (ICX), Ontology (ONT), Bitcoin Gold (BTG), Bytom (BTM), Zcash (ZEC), Nano (NANO), Populous (PPT), Bytecoin (BCN), Steem (STEEM), Wanchain (WAN), Siacoin (SC), Dogecoin (DOGE), Bitcoin Private (BTCP), DigixDAO (DGD), Stratis (STRAT), Waves (WAVES), Zilliqa (ZIL), Bitcoin Diamond (BCD), Decred (DCR), RChain (RHOC), Aeternity (AE), Status (SNT), 0x (ZRX), Loopring (LRC), Komodo (KMD), Aion (AION), Golem (GNT), Ardor (ARDR), IOST (IOST), DigiByte (DGB), KuCoin Shares (KCS), Ark (ARK), Waltonchain (WTC), aelf (ELF), PIVX (PIVX), Centrality (CENNZ), Factom (FCT), Dragonchain (DRGN), Substratum (SUB), QASH (QASH), Veritaseum (VERI), MonaCoin (MONA), Mithril (MITH), Syscoin (SYS), Gas (GAS), Elastos (ELA), Voyager Token (VGX), FunFair (FUN), Nxt (NXT), Nebulas (NAS), Nucleus Vision (NCASH), OByte (GBYTE), ReddCoin (RDD), Revain (REV), WAX (WAX), SALT (SALT), Electroneum (ETN), MaidSafeCoin (MAID), Power Ledger (POWR), Zcoin (XZC), Storm (STORM), Mixin (XIN), Enigma (ENG), Storj (STORJ), TenX (PAY), Neblio (NEBL), Cindicator (CND), Dentacoin (DCN), Particl (PART), Kin (KIN), Skycoin (SKY), Horizen (ZEN), Emercoin (EMC), Civic (CVC), Iconomi (ICN), SmartCash (SMART), SingularityNET (AGI), Matrix AI Network (MAN), POA Network (POA), Nexus (NXS), Achain (ACT), GameCredits (GAME), Dent (DENT), Vertcoin (VTC), Quantstamp (QSP), Gnosis (GNO), iExec RLC (RLC), Decentraland (MANA), Polymath (POLY), Cube (CUBEAUTO), Ubiq (UBQ), Po.et (POE), Genaro Network (GNX), Loom Network (LOOM), NULS (NULS), Dynamic Trading Rights (DTR), Time New Bank (TNB), Aragon (ANT), Enjin Coin (ENJ), Blocknet (BLOCK), High Performance Blockchain (HPB), Raiden Network Token (RDN), Metal (MTL), Santiment Network Token (SAN), Arcblock (ABT), DigitalNote (XDN), Pundi X (NPXS), Bitcore (BTX), Ignis (IGNIS), SIRIN LABS Token (SRN), Dropil (DROP), BOScoin (BOS), Bluzelle (BLZ), DeepBrain Chain (DBC), SmartMesh (SMT), MinexCoin (MNX), Genesis Vision (GVT), Red Pulse Phoenix (PHX), THETA (THETA), NavCoin (NAV), Credits (CS), Pillar (PLR), Paypex (PAYX), THEKEY (TKY), Gifto (GTO), PayPie (PPP), BLOCKv (VEE), Comet (CMT), AirSwap (AST), DEW (DEW), Bibox Token (BIX), OST (OST), ETHLend (LEND), CloakCoin (CLOAK), IoT Chain (ITC), DATA (DTA), BitBay (BAY), Scry.info (DDD), TokenPay (TPAY), Ruff (RUFF), SaluS (SLS), Ripio Credit Network (RCN), Streamr DATAcoin (DATA), SONM (SNM), Quantum Resistant Ledger (QRL), MediBloc [QRC20] (MED), AdEx (ADX), SophiaTX (SPHTX), SingularDTV (SNGLS), Eidoo (EDO), UTRUST (UTK), ION (ION), Einsteinium (EMC2), Ambrosus (AMB), Groestlcoin (GRS), Edgeless (EDG), EvenCoin (EVN), WePower (WPR), Pura (PURA), SpankChain (SPANK), CRYPTO20 (C20), Telcoin (TEL), Peercoin (PPC), Crypterium (CRPT), Oyster Pearl (PRL), MediShares (MDS), Feathercoin (FTC), AppCoins (APPC), USD Coin (USDC), Ripple (XRP), Binance Coin (BNB), Bitcoin Cash (BCH), Bitcoin SV (BSV), Cardano (ADA), Cosmos (ATOM), Dash (DASH), EOS (EOS), Ethereum (ETH), Litecoin (LTC), Monero (XMR), NEM (XEM), Stellar (XLM), Tether (USDT), Tron (TRX), EOSDT, LKSCOIN, HashCan, Polkadot (DOT), BitTorrent (BTT), Alchemy Pay (ACH), renBTC (RENBTC), NXM (NXM), Terra (LUNA), Ampleforth (AMPL), cVault.finance (CORE), xDai (STAKE), Nectar (NEC), Loki (LOKI), sUSD (SUSD), Switcheo (SWTH), SUKU (SUKU), Zap (ZAP), DMM: Governance (DMG), Monolith (TKN), Metronome (MET), YAM v1 (YAM), PieDAO DOUGH v2 (DOUGH), Ferrum Network (FRM), Anyswap (ANY), bitCNY (BITCNY), Hydro Protocol (HOT), Auctus (AUC), Loopring [NEO] (LRN), Jarvis Network (JRT), Rotten (ROT), DeFiner (FIN), Meter Governance (MTRG), Datamine (DAM), Add.xyz (PLT), Compound Dai (CDAI), Compound SAI (CSAI), Compound USD Coin (CUSDC), pTokens BTC (PBTC), DXdao (DXD), WaykiChain Governance Coin (WGRT), Compound Ether (CETH), PieDAO BTC++ (BTC++), Compound Basic Attention Token (CBAT), Compound 0x (CZRX), Compound Wrapped BTC (CWBTC), Compound USDT (CUSDT), Compound Augur (CREP), sBTC (SBTC), sETH (SETH), XinFin Network (XDC), Crypto.com Coin (CRO), UNUS SED LEO (LEO), Filecoin (FIL), Huobi Token (HT), Binance USD (BUSD), Celsius (CEL), FTX Token (FTT), Kusama (KSM), Algorand (ALGO), NEAR Protocol (NEAR), OKB (OKB), TrueUSD (TUSD), HUSD (HUSD), Paxos Standard (PAX), Ocean Protocol (OCEAN), ABBC Coin (ABBC), Celo (CELO), Energy Web Token (EWT), Quant (QNT), Hedera Hashgraph (HBAR), Blockstack (STX), ZB Token (ZB), Solana (SOL), SwissBorg (CHSB), Helium (HNT), DxChain Token (DX), Arweave (AR), The Midas Touch Gold (TMTG), Nervos Network (CKB), IoTeX (IOTX), RSK Infrastructure Framework (RIF), Divi (DIVI), TomoChain (TOMO), Kleros (PNK), Chiliz (CHZ), Uquid Coin (UQC), Ankr (ANKR), Velas (VLX), IRISnet (IRIS), SUN (SUN), Hive (HIVE), Energi (NRG), Unibright (UBT), WAX (WAXP), Fantom (FTM), NAGA Coin, Bestdealstoken, Centyfy, Pi Network (PI), Buddha, INTEXCOIN (INTX), Chia Network (XCH), ThaneCoin, Deviant DEX (DEV), Shiba Inu, Chainlink (LINK), Maker (MKR), FUNToken, Kyber Network (KNC), Toncoin, Haxida (HAX), #MetaHash (MHC), 01coin (ZOC), 0cash (ZCH), 1X2 COIN (1X2), 2GIVE (2GIVE), 42-coin (42), Actinium (ACM), ADAUP (ADAUP), Advanced Internet Blocks (AIB), Advanced Technology Coin (ARC), Aeon (AEON), Aergo (AERGO), Aidos Kuneen (ADK), Akash Network (AKT), Akoin (AKN), Alias (ALIAS), Alliance Fan Token (ALL), AllSafe (ASAFE), AmazonasCoin (AMZ), ANON (ANON), Tiger King Coin (TKING), Arqma (ARQ), Aryacoin (AYA), Auroracoin (AUR), Safe Galaxy (SAFEGALAXY), CumRocket (CUMMIES), AXEL (AXEL), BaaSid (BASS), Bankcoin (BANK), BABB (BAX), Beam (BEAM), Beldex (BDX), BHPCash (BHP), BiblePay (BBP), Sanshu Inu Coin (SANSHU), Baby Shiba Inu (BABYSHIBAINU), Birake (BIR), Bismuth (BIS), Bezoge Earth Coin (BEZOGE), BitCanna (BCNA), Elongate (ELONGATE), ID Coin (MYID), Bitcoin Cash ABC [IOU], Bitcoin Incognito (XBI), Bitcoin Plus (XBC), FEG Token (FEG), Verasity (VRA), Ergo (ERG), Polygon (MATIC), Haxida, CryptoGPT (GPT), Arbitrum (ARB)

Sicurezza

Personal Nessun dato

Anonimità

High Nessun dato

Facilità di uso

Easy Nessun dato

Puoi connettere la carta

no Nessun dato

Ha la possibilità di trading

yes Nessun dato

Ha i voucher e offerte

Nessun dato Nessun dato

Caratteristiche

Hierarchical Deterministic, Open Source, Multi-Signature Nessun dato
About
Counterwallet è un portafoglio web open source anonimo per il protocollo Bitcoin (BTC) e Counterparty (XCP). Counterwallet supporta più lingue. 
XGo ID-Un nome per tutti i tuoi indirizzi Semplifica le tue transazioni crittografiche senza sforzo. Elimina gli indirizzi di portafoglio lunghi e sostituiscili con un singolo nome a tua scelta
Data di lancio Data di lancio 2014 Data di lancio 2021
Località: Località: International Località: International
Lingue Lingue English Lingue English, Japanese, Brazilian Portuguese, Portuguese, German, French, Spanish, Italian, Greek, Korean, Russian, Chinese, Traditional Chinese, Simplified Chinese, Dutch, Vietnamese, Portuguese (PT), Turkish, Indonesian, Malay, Filipino, Hindi, Arabic, Thai, Danish, Hungarian, Polish, Czech, Slovene, Slovak, Ukrainian, Estonian, Taiwanese, Romanian, Hebrew, Finnish, Bulgarian, Bengali, Persian, Swedish, Serbian, Icelandic, Urdu, Croatian
Tipo di portafoglio Tipo di portafoglio Software wallet Tipo di portafoglio Software wallet
Tipo di storage Tipo di storage Hot wallet Tipo di storage Hot wallet
Chiavi private Chiavi private Disponibile Chiavi private Non disponibile
Monete disponibili Monete disponibili 0 Monete disponibili 359 - Bitcoin (BTC), Basic Attention Token (BAT), IOTA (MIOTA), Tezos (XTZ), Ethereum Classic (ETC), NEO (NEO), VeChain (VET), OmiseGO (OMG), Qtum (QTUM), Verge (XVG), Lisk (LSK), ICON (ICX), Ontology (ONT), Bitcoin Gold (BTG), Bytom (BTM), Zcash (ZEC), Nano (NANO), Populous (PPT), Bytecoin (BCN), Steem (STEEM), Wanchain (WAN), Siacoin (SC), Dogecoin (DOGE), Bitcoin Private (BTCP), DigixDAO (DGD), Stratis (STRAT), Waves (WAVES), Zilliqa (ZIL), Bitcoin Diamond (BCD), Decred (DCR), RChain (RHOC), Aeternity (AE), Status (SNT), 0x (ZRX), Loopring (LRC), Komodo (KMD), Aion (AION), Golem (GNT), Ardor (ARDR), IOST (IOST), DigiByte (DGB), KuCoin Shares (KCS), Ark (ARK), Waltonchain (WTC), aelf (ELF), PIVX (PIVX), Centrality (CENNZ), Factom (FCT), Dragonchain (DRGN), Substratum (SUB), QASH (QASH), Veritaseum (VERI), MonaCoin (MONA), Mithril (MITH), Syscoin (SYS), Gas (GAS), Elastos (ELA), Voyager Token (VGX), FunFair (FUN), Nxt (NXT), Nebulas (NAS), Nucleus Vision (NCASH), OByte (GBYTE), ReddCoin (RDD), Revain (REV), WAX (WAX), SALT (SALT), Electroneum (ETN), MaidSafeCoin (MAID), Power Ledger (POWR), Zcoin (XZC), Storm (STORM), Mixin (XIN), Enigma (ENG), Storj (STORJ), TenX (PAY), Neblio (NEBL), Cindicator (CND), Dentacoin (DCN), Particl (PART), Kin (KIN), Skycoin (SKY), Horizen (ZEN), Emercoin (EMC), Civic (CVC), Iconomi (ICN), SmartCash (SMART), SingularityNET (AGI), Matrix AI Network (MAN), POA Network (POA), Nexus (NXS), Achain (ACT), GameCredits (GAME), Dent (DENT), Vertcoin (VTC), Quantstamp (QSP), Gnosis (GNO), iExec RLC (RLC), Decentraland (MANA), Polymath (POLY), Cube (CUBEAUTO), Ubiq (UBQ), Po.et (POE), Genaro Network (GNX), Loom Network (LOOM), NULS (NULS), Dynamic Trading Rights (DTR), Time New Bank (TNB), Aragon (ANT), Enjin Coin (ENJ), Blocknet (BLOCK), High Performance Blockchain (HPB), Raiden Network Token (RDN), Metal (MTL), Santiment Network Token (SAN), Arcblock (ABT), DigitalNote (XDN), Pundi X (NPXS), Bitcore (BTX), Ignis (IGNIS), SIRIN LABS Token (SRN), Dropil (DROP), BOScoin (BOS), Bluzelle (BLZ), DeepBrain Chain (DBC), SmartMesh (SMT), MinexCoin (MNX), Genesis Vision (GVT), Red Pulse Phoenix (PHX), THETA (THETA), NavCoin (NAV), Credits (CS), Pillar (PLR), Paypex (PAYX), THEKEY (TKY), Gifto (GTO), PayPie (PPP), BLOCKv (VEE), Comet (CMT), AirSwap (AST), DEW (DEW), Bibox Token (BIX), OST (OST), ETHLend (LEND), CloakCoin (CLOAK), IoT Chain (ITC), DATA (DTA), BitBay (BAY), Scry.info (DDD), TokenPay (TPAY), Ruff (RUFF), SaluS (SLS), Ripio Credit Network (RCN), Streamr DATAcoin (DATA), SONM (SNM), Quantum Resistant Ledger (QRL), MediBloc [QRC20] (MED), AdEx (ADX), SophiaTX (SPHTX), SingularDTV (SNGLS), Eidoo (EDO), UTRUST (UTK), ION (ION), Einsteinium (EMC2), Ambrosus (AMB), Groestlcoin (GRS), Edgeless (EDG), EvenCoin (EVN), WePower (WPR), Pura (PURA), SpankChain (SPANK), CRYPTO20 (C20), Telcoin (TEL), Peercoin (PPC), Crypterium (CRPT), Oyster Pearl (PRL), MediShares (MDS), Feathercoin (FTC), AppCoins (APPC), USD Coin (USDC), Ripple (XRP), Binance Coin (BNB), Bitcoin Cash (BCH), Bitcoin SV (BSV), Cardano (ADA), Cosmos (ATOM), Dash (DASH), EOS (EOS), Ethereum (ETH), Litecoin (LTC), Monero (XMR), NEM (XEM), Stellar (XLM), Tether (USDT), Tron (TRX), EOSDT, LKSCOIN, HashCan, Polkadot (DOT), BitTorrent (BTT), Alchemy Pay (ACH), renBTC (RENBTC), NXM (NXM), Terra (LUNA), Ampleforth (AMPL), cVault.finance (CORE), xDai (STAKE), Nectar (NEC), Loki (LOKI), sUSD (SUSD), Switcheo (SWTH), SUKU (SUKU), Zap (ZAP), DMM: Governance (DMG), Monolith (TKN), Metronome (MET), YAM v1 (YAM), PieDAO DOUGH v2 (DOUGH), Ferrum Network (FRM), Anyswap (ANY), bitCNY (BITCNY), Hydro Protocol (HOT), Auctus (AUC), Loopring [NEO] (LRN), Jarvis Network (JRT), Rotten (ROT), DeFiner (FIN), Meter Governance (MTRG), Datamine (DAM), Add.xyz (PLT), Compound Dai (CDAI), Compound SAI (CSAI), Compound USD Coin (CUSDC), pTokens BTC (PBTC), DXdao (DXD), WaykiChain Governance Coin (WGRT), Compound Ether (CETH), PieDAO BTC++ (BTC++), Compound Basic Attention Token (CBAT), Compound 0x (CZRX), Compound Wrapped BTC (CWBTC), Compound USDT (CUSDT), Compound Augur (CREP), sBTC (SBTC), sETH (SETH), XinFin Network (XDC), Crypto.com Coin (CRO), UNUS SED LEO (LEO), Filecoin (FIL), Huobi Token (HT), Binance USD (BUSD), Celsius (CEL), FTX Token (FTT), Kusama (KSM), Algorand (ALGO), NEAR Protocol (NEAR), OKB (OKB), TrueUSD (TUSD), HUSD (HUSD), Paxos Standard (PAX), Ocean Protocol (OCEAN), ABBC Coin (ABBC), Celo (CELO), Energy Web Token (EWT), Quant (QNT), Hedera Hashgraph (HBAR), Blockstack (STX), ZB Token (ZB), Solana (SOL), SwissBorg (CHSB), Helium (HNT), DxChain Token (DX), Arweave (AR), The Midas Touch Gold (TMTG), Nervos Network (CKB), IoTeX (IOTX), RSK Infrastructure Framework (RIF), Divi (DIVI), TomoChain (TOMO), Kleros (PNK), Chiliz (CHZ), Uquid Coin (UQC), Ankr (ANKR), Velas (VLX), IRISnet (IRIS), SUN (SUN), Hive (HIVE), Energi (NRG), Unibright (UBT), WAX (WAXP), Fantom (FTM), NAGA Coin, Bestdealstoken, Centyfy, Pi Network (PI), Buddha, INTEXCOIN (INTX), Chia Network (XCH), ThaneCoin, Deviant DEX (DEV), Shiba Inu, Chainlink (LINK), Maker (MKR), FUNToken, Kyber Network (KNC), Toncoin, Haxida (HAX), #MetaHash (MHC), 01coin (ZOC), 0cash (ZCH), 1X2 COIN (1X2), 2GIVE (2GIVE), 42-coin (42), Actinium (ACM), ADAUP (ADAUP), Advanced Internet Blocks (AIB), Advanced Technology Coin (ARC), Aeon (AEON), Aergo (AERGO), Aidos Kuneen (ADK), Akash Network (AKT), Akoin (AKN), Alias (ALIAS), Alliance Fan Token (ALL), AllSafe (ASAFE), AmazonasCoin (AMZ), ANON (ANON), Tiger King Coin (TKING), Arqma (ARQ), Aryacoin (AYA), Auroracoin (AUR), Safe Galaxy (SAFEGALAXY), CumRocket (CUMMIES), AXEL (AXEL), BaaSid (BASS), Bankcoin (BANK), BABB (BAX), Beam (BEAM), Beldex (BDX), BHPCash (BHP), BiblePay (BBP), Sanshu Inu Coin (SANSHU), Baby Shiba Inu (BABYSHIBAINU), Birake (BIR), Bismuth (BIS), Bezoge Earth Coin (BEZOGE), BitCanna (BCNA), Elongate (ELONGATE), ID Coin (MYID), Bitcoin Cash ABC [IOU], Bitcoin Incognito (XBI), Bitcoin Plus (XBC), FEG Token (FEG), Verasity (VRA), Ergo (ERG), Polygon (MATIC), Haxida, CryptoGPT (GPT), Arbitrum (ARB)
Sicurezza Sicurezza Personal Sicurezza Nessun dato
Anonimità Anonimità High Anonimità Nessun dato
Facilità di uso Facilità di uso Easy Facilità di uso Nessun dato
Puoi connettere la carta Puoi connettere la carta no Puoi connettere la carta Nessun dato
Ha la possibilità di trading Ha la possibilità di trading yes Ha la possibilità di trading Nessun dato
Ha i voucher e offerte Ha i voucher e offerte Nessun dato Ha i voucher e offerte Nessun dato
Caratteristiche Caratteristiche Hierarchical Deterministic, Open Source, Multi-Signature Caratteristiche Nessun dato

Media

Sito web

counterwallet.io xgo.id

Twitter

Nessun dato @XGo_official
Sito web Sito web counterwallet.io Sito web xgo.id
Twitter Twitter Nessun dato Twitter @XGo_official

Vantaggi

- Open-source Un ricco set di criptovalute supportate Crypto swap supportati Supporto per MetaMask, Coinbase e altri portafogli Convenienza di XGo ID

Svantaggi

- Scelta limitata di monete Azienda giovane

Valutazione

User rating User rating 5 / 5 1 recensione dell'utente User rating 5 / 5 1 recensione dell'utente
Cryptogeek rating Cryptogeek rating 5 / 5 Cryptogeek rating 4.8 / 5
Vantaggi Vantaggi - Open-source Vantaggi Un ricco set di criptovalute supportate Crypto swap supportati Supporto per MetaMask, Coinbase e altri portafogli Convenienza di XGo ID
Svantaggi Svantaggi - Scelta limitata di monete Svantaggi Azienda giovane

La valutazione degli utenti di Counterwallet è 5, basata sulle recensioni degli utenti di 1. La valutazione degli utenti dell'azienda XGo ID Wallet è 5, basata sulle recensioni degli utenti di 1.

We also calculate the special Cryptogeek TrustScore based on the characteristics of each wallet.

Scegliamo il vincitore in base al nostro Punteggio di Fiducia. Ricorda, dipende ancora da te quale compagnia scegliere! Come calcoliamo Il Punteggio di Fiducia?
logo-img
Punteggio di Fiducia: 4.55 / 5 Scrivi la tua recensione
Punteggio di Fiducia: 4.13 / 5 Scrivi la tua recensione
Scegli altre aziende
Through this comparative examination of XGo ID Wallet and Counterwallet, we must conclude that both wallets come with their own unique sets of features and security parameters. One may be preferable over the other based on your specific needs and usage requirements. As end users, we must thoroughly understand these variances to select the solution that best aligns with our virtual asset management needs. It is always crucial to choose a wallet that ensures the best security, convenience, and user experience.
As the digital world continues to expand, choosing the right digital wallet becomes increasingly important for the management of our virtual assets. In this article, we will dive into a head to head comparison between two popular wallets - XGo ID Wallet and Counterwallet. This deep comparison will look into their key features, security aspects, ease of use, and more, so you can make an informed decision.